Parts for 257191501 — Craftsman

We found 20 parts confirmed to fit the Craftsman 257191501.

Compatibility table

Prices shown are an informational reference range only, not an offer or an Amazon price — RepairKitHub does not sell parts directly. Each part links to an Amazon search so you can compare current listings yourself.

Common failure areas on this model

The confirmed parts above group into a handful of failure areas. Here is what each points to and how to check it before you order anything.

General hardware and mounting parts

Symptom: A small mechanical or mounting part has failed, cracked, or gone missing.

Check: Compare the physical shape and mounting points to the original piece, and confirm the exact part number against your model plate before ordering.

Parts in this group on 257191501: 964324 (Grinding Wheel), 42821 (Nameplate), 964323 (Grinding Wheel), 4365016 (Whl Cvr Rh), 4686116 (End Frame Rh), 22001619 (Stator/coil), 5219135 (Tool Rst Arm), 22001637 (Relay), 5319132 (Tool Rest Rh), 4971959 (Lamp Shade), 5538409 (Spark Pack), STD541350 (NUT - R.H.), STD522522 (BOLT - 1/4-20 X 2-1/4 HX HEAD (STANDARD HARDWARE ITEMS - MAY BE PURCHASED LOCALLY.)), STD551237 (Lock Washer), AGM73610701 (LG Washer Magnetic Door Plunger AGM73610701).

Storage, trim and cosmetic hardware

Symptom: A cracked shelf, broken door bin, worn hinge, or missing trim piece -- cosmetic and storage wear rather than a functional breakdown.

Check: Match the physical dimensions and mounting tabs of the old part before ordering; these pieces are often model-specific even between visually similar models.

Parts in this group on 257191501: 3169206 (Grommet), 4505 (Axle Support), 4971958 (Cover), STD600802 (Screw).

Heat control (thermostats, fuses, heating element)

Symptom: The appliance runs but heats or cools inconsistently, or shuts off partway through a cycle.

Check: With the appliance unplugged, check continuity across the part with a multimeter -- no continuity means it has failed.

Parts in this group on 257191501: 29101987 (Char-Broil Electric Grill Heating Element).

Before you buy

Match 257191501 exactly against the model and serial plate on the appliance itself before ordering anything — a single mismatched character can point to a different production run with different parts. Then check the part number printed or stamped on the part you are replacing against the part numbers in the table above; the printed number is the most reliable way to confirm fitment when a model has gone through multiple production runs. RepairKitHub does not sell parts directly — every part link above routes to an Amazon search for that part number so you can compare current listings and sellers yourself.

How to confirm this is your model

Check inside a door opening, on a back or side panel, or behind a removable panel or drawer for a label printed with the model and serial number. Match every character exactly, including letters and dashes at the end — appliance model numbers often have similar prefixes but different suffixes for different production runs.

Still not sure?

Use the model lookup tool to search by model or part number, or start from the symptom your appliance is showing.